Real Analysis · Undergraduate
Differentiability: The Derivative as a Limit
Quick answer
A function is differentiable at c when the difference quotient (f(x) − f(c))/(x − c) has a limit as x → c; that limit is f′(c). Every differentiable function is continuous, since f(x) − f(c) equals the quotient times (x − c), which tends to f′(c) · 0. The converse fails: |x| is continuous at 0, but its one-sided quotients tend to 1 and −1. And x² sin(1/x) is differentiable at 0 with derivative 0, even though its derivative has no limit there.
What you'll learn
- Compute a derivative from the limit definition
- Prove that differentiability implies continuity
- Show a function is not differentiable using one-sided limits
- Analyze x² sin(1/x) at 0
The derivative as a limit
A function is differentiable at when this limit exists:
The limit is the one from continuity, applied to the difference quotient, which is undefined at itself. A two-sided limit exists exactly when the left-hand and right-hand limits exist and agree.
- y = x² sin(1/x)
- y = ±x²
Why differentiable functions are continuous
For , write
As , the first factor tends to and the second to . By the product rule for limits, , which says is continuous at . The argument needs the quotient to have a finite limit, and that is exactly what lacks at .
Worked examples
Common mistakes
Practice problems
-
Use the definition to find for .
Answer
Full solution
.
-
Find .
Answer
Full solution
For , .
-
Find .
Answer
Full solution
For , .
-
Is differentiable at ?
Answer
Yes
Full solution
The quotient is , so .
-
Find for .
Answer
Full solution
Near , , so .
-
Is differentiable at ?
Answer
No
Full solution
The one-sided quotients tend to and .
-
Use the definition to find for .
Answer
Full solution
.
-
For with , a student tries to evaluate at . Find from the definition.
Answer
Full solution
The quotient is squeezed to .
Frequently asked questions
What does differentiable at c mean?
The limit of (f(x) − f(c))/(x − c) as x → c exists. Its value is f′(c).
Does differentiable imply continuous?
Yes. f(x) − f(c) = [(f(x) − f(c))/(x − c)] · (x − c), which tends to f′(c) · 0 = 0.
Does continuous imply differentiable?
No. |x| is continuous at 0 but not differentiable there.
Can a derivative exist everywhere but not be continuous?
Yes. f(x) = x² sin(1/x) with f(0) = 0 has f′(0) = 0, but f′(x) = 2x sin(1/x) − cos(1/x) has no limit as x → 0.